Burning Astronaut Pee – Smarter Every Day 149

Burning Astronaut Pee – Smarter Every Day 149


Hey it’s me Destin, welcome back to Smarter Every Day When I make a video, I normally ask a question and have a pretty good idea – – of where that question is going to take me. This one is way different. We’re going to start in a weight room and we are going to end up deep in the bowels of Johnson Space Center, where we meet a lady who literally burns astronaut pee. We all know in space if an astronaut sits around he is going to lose muscle mass But Earth is different
When I lift this weight, it’s actually weight So here is my question, how do astronauts lift weights in space? To learn the answer to this, lets go talk to astronauts Don Pettit and Mike Hopkins It doesn’t look like you’ve been lifting quite as much as this man over here I’m Destin
Hi Destin, I’m Mike
Mike, nice to meet you And Mike, you’re an expert at working out in space right? Well I’ve spent some time working out here on Earth, and, ah, I just took that to space with me You take people like Mike and I
(Destin) Studs, lets be clear, studs right? People like Mike and I
(Destin laughs) And, you know, we’re in the middle of life, we’re healthy, and we go to station And we get disease like symptoms instilled in our bodies, from any number of venues, physiological venues And it’s a great way to study the effect of these things and what’s causing them and how to prevent them Some of these diseases we’re talking about take years to manifest here on Earth, but up in space we’ll see them in months – (Destin) Right
– or weeks, so that’s another advantage to doing it up in orbit (Destin) Oh that makes sense
And we’re working right now this machine which I like to call ‘The Beast’ – everybody calls it the ARED
(Destin) Which stands for what? – ah you know… (Dr Bob) Advanced Resistive Exercise Device
(Destin) Advanced resistive
(Don) This is Dr Bob
(Mike) He is the expert (Destin) Dr Bob…you got to keep these astronauts straight It takes some special engineering thinking to make a machine that allows you to weight lift in a weightless environment Before Dr Bob explains how ARED works I wanted to see if I could figure this out My first thought was to use a spring, but the more you compress a spring the more force is required Weight is a constant force, so that doesn’t work I thought about the same thing with elastic bands, but the more you stretch them, the more force is required, so that doesn’t work either My final thought was to use an air cylinder If you plug one end of the air cylinder and you compressed it that would work up to a point, but as the volume decreases, pressure increases requiring more force So how did they do it? The heart of the system are these two canisters right here
(Destin) Okay These two canisters contain a vacuum
Now if we could look inside the canister you would see a piston that would slide (Destin) OH! Wait a second! Because a vacuum never changes Yeah the vacuum is always the same, its always a vacuum (Destin) So instead of pressurizing air and pushing against something you’re just going to pull it The volume of your vacuum is right here between the piston and the top of the chamber
(Destin) Okay Now you pan down, attached to the piston is a rod that comes on down here and attaches here and here (Destin) Okay
So the vacuum always wants to pull those rods up (Destin) Like a syringe
Like a syringe, exactly like a syringe (Destin) Okay this is really clever, think about it
You got a cylinder, a piston and the atmospheric pressure all around If you push the piston in all the way and you close the valve at the end, and you pull, you’re going to create a vacuum – because the normal air pressure on the inside of the station is pushing on the backside of the piston it creates a force More importantly, a constant force
This is super simple and super clever So as the vacuum pulls the pistons up, it forces this arm down
So pistons go up, arm goes down and that is constant And so right now the vacuum is holding this arm to this upper stop
When Mike stands up it will release And now he is holding that 50 pounds in this example on his shoulders (Destin) Okay, it’s way more complicated than I thought it was
Okay one more time please Mike? (Mike) Okay, here we go
(Destin) Going down
(Mike) Going down (Dr Bob) Vacuum is pressing him down, and now he is standing up against the force of the vacuum (Don) Destin, this is just simple levers
(Destin) This is Archimedes (Don) First class, second class Don’s right, it’s just a lever
If the vacuum is pulling up on one side of the bar, it’s going to be pushing down with a constant force on the other Another cool thing is if you vary the position of the fulcrum, you can vary the weight In fact, they’ve got an easy way to adjust that, so a guy like me can work out with guys like Mike and Don (Destin) Okay…wow feels like weight – it feels exactly like weight (Don) That’s how it was designed (Destin) Okay, so here’s a question, so is this all about muscle? It’s all about muscle –
(Destin) Okay
– its about bones (Destin) What do you mean?
Ah bone density, loading your skeletal system (Destin) I though when you work out, you’re working out because of your muscles
(Dr Bob) You are…ah, you’re also putting loads on your skeletal system – – most notably the hip area, the spine area…everything kind of below the waist you don’t use in space (Destin) So what does loading the bone do for you, you said bone density? (Dr Bob) Yes, ah, loading the bone stimulates bone growth –
(Destin) Okay – so we want to minimize any losses by stimulating the bones as much as we can
(Destin) Okay, is that a big deal in space? It’s a huge deal
(Destin) What do you mean it’s a huge deal? Well, without that, you can stand to loose – – two to two and a half percent of your bone density per month Did you hear what he said?
2 to 2.5% per MONTH!
That’s crazy if you extrapolate that out – – your bones are going to be gone (Destin) So after 30 months you have half your bone density? Possibly, but no ones ever
I mean we don’t send people to the space station and NOT have them exercise Okay if it takes three years to get to Mars and back, a certain percentage of your bone mineral density lost every month is a huge deal! So I started poring through the data and I learned that the bulk of that bone mineral density loss is lost in the lower back, in the hip and in the femur – – and if you think about it, that makes sense, because where do the elderly most often break a bone? So to understand this even better I went to the Nutritional Biochemistry Lab there at Johnson Space Centre – – and I learned, that the majority of those minerals are being pee-d out of the astronauts bodies I’m with Doctor Scott Smith and you are part of the Nutritional Biochemistry team here at NASA Johnson Space Centre…that’s a really nice logo, I like that So I noticed that you have pee on the counter here – Why is this so important? We’ll we’re a nutritional biochemistry lab so we look at biochemistry, um, a lot of the work that we do is focused on bone – – because there is a lot of things in your body, um, there’s a lot of things in your diet that relate to your bones – – so things like calcium and other factors all effect your bones, so we’re very interested in looking at those things – – and the easiest way to do that is by looking at blood samples and urine samples Your body is pretty smart, and it maintains the skeleton that you need to do what you’re doing – – what that means is that you’re forming as much bone as you’re breaking down (Destin) It’s like this cycle and you’re making bone and you’re loosing it at the same time
(Scott) Right, and as long as you’re doing those two things at the same rate, then all is good (Destin) Okay
(Scott) When you start doing more of one than the other is when you get out of balance This is one -80F freezer and we got another dozen or so upstairs, we’ve got another dozen or so two hours away in a bunker that we protect them – – so that if a hurricane hits here and the power goes off, we don’t loose those samples Are you serious? So you gotta protect the astronaut pee?
Yes, like you wouldn’t believe It is considered a National Treasure That’s my goal in life, is for my pee to be considered a National Treasure
It’s not quite what the moon rocks are… You’re being serious, because I mean if you think about it like, you can’t reproduce it, because the amount of money and tax-payer dollars that went into creating – – that specific controlled astronaut pee, is irreplaceable
That’s correct If you want, Anna’s here…Anna’s running urine calcium’s right now (Destin) Really (Destin) So Ann, you’re taking the urine and you’re putting it into the machine? Yes, I’m diluting it, 1:100 (Destin) How does it feel to know that a National Treasure is in your hands? That National Treasure being astronaut urine… It’s really something special (Destin laughing) What a great way to answer that question! This instrument is looking at urinary calcium (Destin) So you’re saying that this is where the bone mass goes? They pee out their bones
(Scott) That is correct, they pee out their bones (Destin) WOAH (Destin) There’s a fire going on in here! You didn’t tell me that! No, I didn’t tell you
(Destin) What’s up with the fire? (Scott) The machine injects a sample into that flame
(Destin) Okay And then as it burns, what happens is the machine measures the absorption of light and based on standards and curves, um – – you’re looking at…its absorbs different wavelengths from that heat and tells you where the calcium is There’s a lot of big words happening right here, but I want us to stop and think about what’s actually happening We’re taking astronaut pee, and we’re burning it, and we’re looking at the colour of burnt astronaut pee – – is that correct?
That’s correct In crew members with the ARED, when they came back, when we looked at their X-Rays – – their bone mineral density was the same as it was before flight (Destin) And that’s never happened before?
(Scott) And that’s never happened before, with good diet and hard exercise (Scott) This is the percent change, per month, in whole body bone mineral density
(Destin) Okay (Scott) In crew members in the MIR, where they didn’t have any resistive exercise – In crew members early on station where they had the iRED, and crew members with the ARED (Destin) BOOM, can’t go to Mars, can’t go to Mars, you can go to Mars (Scott) Theoretically yes
(Destin) Because of ARED (Scott) And again, there is still questions about strength and the core (Destin) I get it, but let’s go to Mars
Seriously! That’s, like, that data is very very clear (Scott) That’s what we thought (Destin) Another thing that is really cool about this research is that all these papers that are being cranked out by the biochemistry lab at NASA – – are not just applicable to space
In the future these lessons about diet and skeletal loading will also help people like my granny – – who is currently recovering from a broken hip, and to me, that’s a huge deal Okay, I hope you enjoyed this episode of Smarter Every Day Smarter Every Day is sponsored by Audible.com, and this is the book I want you to get It’s called Packing for Mars by Mary Roach, and I listened to this thing on the way out to Houston It’s a really really good book, I enjoyed it a lot, it’s about the weird things that the human body does when you put it in space What happens to all the stuff that your skin excretes, how does your body detect blood pressure, how is that effected by the gravity vector, all kinds of weird stuff Human bodies do, you know, crude things, so you’re not going to want to listen to this around the kids I cannot recommend this enough: Packing for Mars by Mary Roach You can get that for free from Audible.com/smarter
I think you’ll like it Also, feel free to check out the rest of the space series, if you feel like this episode earned your subscription, feel free to do that – – or even support on Patreon, but only if it earned it Anyway, thank you so much for watching I’m Destin, you’re getting Smarter Every Day
Have a good one (Destin) Wow, feels like weight, it feels exactly like weight (Don) That’s how it was designed (Destin) So I can feel the inertia from those flywheels (Don) Those little details are really important when you get in a weightless environment (Destin) Holy cow, it feels like I’ve got weight on my shoulders (Don) And it just shows that what engineers can do when they’re given, ah, a challenging project and you give them free reign to come up with a design (Destin) Like I don’t like lifting weights and I’m already sad
That’s amazing

100 Replies to “Burning Astronaut Pee – Smarter Every Day 149”

  1. how would a person without legs fare in space? I guess it would depend on where their torso ends right? how would it affect their spine?

  2. They should use electricity generating resistant device to workout and more power. It’s a win win!!!

  3. @Smarter Every Day at 2:10 I didn't understand why a rubber band like resistance wouldn't work in space?

  4. Okay, so I did a quick search for the cost of ARED but couldn't find anything. Do you have those details? Thanks.

  5. This is four years later. Don must REALLY be ripped by now. Lol
    Good stuff. Very interesting and I just got a little smarter. 👍👍
    I can't believe that I'm just now seeing this. 5/27/2019

  6. That's really interesting. You can't deny the facts. That should give the Orion/Mars crews a much better health situation. Bravo!

  7. Can't the offset the bone density reduction via having the Astronauts sleep in pods that reverberate with cat purring?

  8. This seems way too over thought. Surely someone way more intelligent than me has heard of resistance training with bands right? Why couldn't a box full of bands with some hooks and bars and handles replace this apparatus? Resistance training can work with zero gravity can it not?

    Edited to sound way less cunty.

  9. Is there any way to replicate different conditions like weigthless on earth. In a curiosity question. How much energy does the body require to be in space. Since there is not much resistance going on. How did Nasa knew how the heart would behave. Does basic funcions require help. Wow have so many questions.

  10. For the exercise equipment in space, can you explain why they can't just use a similar piston and a computer to dictate how much resistance it provides? That seems like the easiest solution to me but i'm obviously missing why this wouldn't work, because if it would, they'd be doing it.

  11. Got real excited when I see chemistry equipment, terminology and knowledge I’ve been doing in year 11 high school chemistry in NASA labs

  12. What's the reason ARED won the bone lost battle and iRED (it's predecessor) didn't? How iRED differs from the former one? Cannot find any resource on iRED. It doesn't hold the constant force or something?

  13. I don't get how using a vacuum works. I would have thought it would get harder to lift, because it will resist more as the vacuum increases.
    Why not just use springs and design the system so that the fulcrum changes proportional to how harder it gets?

  14. this is how people from NASA do it. An ordinary common sense thinking person might put a spring there and then compensate the uneven force with a cam and a rope.

  15. I guess the Russians would just bring a metal bar, a few large rubber bands, and connect everything to two hooks in the hull…

  16. The Earth is Flat and we never went to the Moon. But other than that…Great vid, as usual. 😉

  17. Ok here is something to think about. I contend that the system on the space station does not deliver constant force. Despite pulling against a vacuum the space station is a closed air tight environment meaning that the side of the piston that is exposed to air does push against the pressure in the station causing a ramp up I’m resistance. Admittedly this would be small and Insignificant however this system still delivers a non constant force to the user.

  18. Wow look, it took some space engineers that went to school their whole lives to figure out how to make an ultra complicated bike pump 🙂

  19. Notice how the old guy is flexing after Destin says his muscle are small… 0:39 then 0:54. Also very annoying.

  20. I feel like I'm missing something, but even with a vacuum the pulling force on the piston should increase, no?
    So how would that differ from using a spring?

  21. Destin should be a teacher or something. I did commercial studies in school but I'm learning this science thing easy

  22. My pee is used for treating wood fences the smell lasts for about a year, but it stains well and lasts for decades.

  23. I also read packing for mars, I agree that it is definitely worth the read. It details the unseen aspects of spaceflight.

  24. i was so engrossed in learning about how the machine for weightlifting works hat i didn't realise what the purpose of this video was until he said "peed out" at 6:11 . now that's how make an amazing entertaining and informative video. love your explanations and your energy, would love to have you as a teacher, earned my subscription

  25. The Light Absorption principle is also how the Breath Test Analyzers work, that measure alcohol content of breath samples for a suspected DUI Driver. Driving under influence. Maybe a future episode ?

  26. I am constantly amazed by your variety of subject matter. Your abilities to teach and demonstrate complex scenarios makes it fun to help understand the issue at hand.
    FUTURE IDEA – Subject: Stem Cells, Medical applications for Autologous stem cells, Embryonic Stem Cells, and umbilical cord stem cells.
    This my field and physicians are just now appreciating the healing values of this rejuvenative biologic for a large amount of human body ailments. I hope you will consider doing some videos on this subject.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *